All Collections |
---|
ETHICS AGENCIES |
---|
(Conflicts of Interest Board) |
(Department of Investigation) |
(NYS Joint Commission on Public Ethics) |
Type your search keywords below
Total results: 544
File: 24-1588.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/13/24 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel. Morgan
v. NY Pyramid Group
OATH Index No. 1588/24 (Nov. 7, 2024)
In default proceeding, petitioner established that respondent refused
to accept a city-issued housing voucher from the complainant.
Mental anguish damages of $10,000 recommended, along wi...
File: 24-1879.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. E.B.
OATH Index No. 1879/24 (June 21, 2024), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Aug. 9, 2024), appended
The Department proved that Respondent engaged in misconduct
when she used profanity during an altercation with another
correction officer and when speaking to a capta...
File: 24-2195.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/17/24 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights v. M. B.
OATH Index No. 2195/24 (July 26, 2024), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Sept. 6, 2024), appended
Evidence established that respondent was absent without
authorization on 159 dates from May 2022 to November 2023.
Termination recommended.
__________________________...
File: 21-1699.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
evidence of a disability), and its progeny...v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp., 88 A...caused by a disability, it may still...she has a disability, only
the determination...that respondent is disabled. Petitioner claims that...for terminating a disabled employee
who has...caused by a disability and has, instead...duties due to disability. See e.g. Health & Hospitals Corp. (Lincoln Medical...related to a
disability, alcoholism, and was
File: 10-2742.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp.
(Bellevue Hospital Ctr.) v. A. S.
OATH Index No. 2742/10 (Sept. 27, 2010), rejected, Exec. Dir. Dec. (Dec. 15, 2010), appended
ALJ recommends dismissal of AWOL charges where absence was
caused by employer’s improper refusal to allow respondent to
return to wo...
File: 12-1781.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
attributable to a disability, and respondent, by...virtue of that disability, is unable to...caused by
a disability, no penalty for...be imposed. Health & Hospitals
Corp. (Lincoln Medical...to a mental disability and noting that...to pursue a
disability proceeding); Dep’t...mental or physical disability”);
Housing Auth. v...due to a disability would lead to...issue.
In a disability proceeding, petitioner bears...suffers from a disability, that he is
File: 09-2448.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. A. S.
OATH Index No. 2448/09 (Sept. 30, 2009)
ALJ recommended dismissal of medical separation charge
under section 73, finding officer currently fit to work.
Respondent was guilty of misconduct separately charged
under section 75 for which ALJ recommended a 20-...
File: 11-248.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Elmhurst Hosp. Ctr.) v. J.E.
OATH Index No. 248/11 (Sept. 14, 2011)
Petitioner proved that respondent was excessively absent and late
for work. Termination of employment recommended where
respondent recently served 25-day, 40-day, and 60-day
suspensions for simi...
File: 12-771.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
by his alleged disability); see also Ricketts...v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp., 88 A...caused by his disability).
Here, it is...not respondent’s disability caused her absences...002, Enforcement Guidance: Disability-Related Inquiries and...establish that a disability was the cause
File: 12-1546.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1546/12 (Sept. 6, 2012)
Fitness proceeding brought against motor vehicle driver. ALJ
found evidence sufficient to establish that employee had a
disability, but insufficient to establish that she was unable to
perform her job a...
File: 23-2135.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 3/26/24 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Elmhurst Hospital Ctr.) v. Hewitt
OATH Index No. 2135/23 (Feb. 15, 2024)
Evidence established that respondent has been excessively absent
since November 2020 and absent without leave since May 2022.
Termination recommended.
_______________________________...
File: JW0004189.pdf
Agency: OATH_HEARINGS
Date: 12/9/24 12:00 AM
he] has been disabled
through illness . . . .” Here...use due to disability as Respondent asserted...did not establish disability during the period...did not
establish disability as he asserted...that he was hospitalized for seven to...bones or other disability).
Accordingly, the Tribunal
File: 11-1997.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
suffered from a disability); see also Health & Hospitals Corp. (Metropolitan
Hospital Ctr.) v. Ricketts, OATH...
File: 19-348.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
to a local
hospital (Tr. 138, 146...applied for a disability retirement. In July...respondent was presently disabled from returning to...application for a disability retirement. The Medical
File: 11-932.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Health & Mental Hygiene
v. C. L.
OATH Index No. 932/11 (Mar. 2, 2011), adopted in part, modified in part,
Comm’r Dec. (Apr. 12, 2011), appended
In default proceeding decided on submitted papers, the evidence
established that respondent has been continuously absent fro...
File: 21-391.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Authority
v. A.A.
OATH Index No. 391/21 (Feb. 8, 2022)
Bridge and tunnel officer was insubordinate in failing to provide
certain medical documentation required by medical review officer.
However, petitioner failed to prove that respondent was AWOL b...
File: 13-212.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 212/13 (Nov. 21, 2012), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD 13-25-
SA (May 13, 2013), appended
Evidence established that respondent was repeatedly intoxicated at
work. Termination of employment recommended in light of
responden...
File: 14-2757.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. A.A.
OATH Index No. 2757/14 (May 22, 2015), modified, Comm’r Dec. (Oct. 23, 2015), appended,
modified, NYC Civ Serv. Comm’n Case No. 2015-1317 (Feb. 4, 2016). appended
Respondent, a civilian employee, engaged in misconduct when he
committed an off-duty as...
File: 14-2183.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Police Dep’t v. A.A.
OATH Index No. 2183/14 (June 30, 2015)
Petitioner proved that respondent is unfit to perform the duties of a
traffic enforcement agent. Leave of absence under section 72 of
the Civil Service Law recommended.
__________________________________________________...
File: 10-1472.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1472/10 (June 16, 2010)
Petitioner established that respondent has been absent in excess of
one year due to a non work-related disability and that he is
currently unfit to perform the duties of a correction officer.
Dismissal from employm...
File: 08-1867.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Housing Authority v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1867/08 (June 26, 2008)
Authority sought to place housing assistant on involuntary leave
pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law, based upon
diagnosis that employee has a seizure disorder. Finding that the
Authority had not met its bur...
File: 12-0802.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. J.G.
OATH Index No. 802/12 (Mar. 9, 2012), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Aug. 23, 2012)
Evidence established that sanitation worker’s AWOL was due to
his disability. Dismissal of charges recommended as respondent
lacked requisite intent to commit misconduct.
_________...
File: 15-1003.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Transit Auth. v. D.S.
OATH Index No. 1003/15 (Mar. 31, 2015)
Associate staff analyst admitted making inappropriate statements
constituting threats to a supervisor and was found guilty of
misconduct. Considering mitigation evidence related to the recent
death of his wife, ALJ recommends a...
File: 21-0484.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Transit Authority v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 484/21 (May 3, 2021)
Respondent activated a fire alarm on an elevator and yelled “fire”
when there was no fire, threw a metal stand at a co-worker, and
failed to report the ensuing arrest promptly. Penalty of 60 days’
suspension...
File: 15-2343.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. M.C.
OATH Index No. 2343/15 (Mar. 17, 2016)
Charges that correction officer attempted to shoplift from Macy’s
on two occasions were not sustained because the evidence that he
intended to steal the merchandise was equivocal. Charge that he
failed to no...
File: 18-1865.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Housing Auth. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1865/18 (May 3, 2018), rejected, Auth. Dec. (May 16, 2018), appended
Fitness proceeding brought against customer information
representative. ALJ found evidence insufficient to establish that
employee’s disability rendered him unable to p...
File: 13-2246.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2246/13 (Oct. 31, 2013)
Clerical associate accessed confidential public assistance records
without authorization; posted items on the wall of his cubicle and
maintained items in a folder on his desk to intimidate his
supervisor; provided ...
File: 12-212.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 212/12 (Dec. 15, 2011)
Petitioner established by a preponderance of the credible evidence
that Child Protective Specialist Supervisor II was unfit to perform
the duties of her position due to a disability.
____________________...
File: 16-858.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Parks &Recreation v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 858/16 (Apr. 12, 2016)
Petitioner demonstrated that respondent, a computer associate, is
currently unfit for the duties of his job and should be on a leave
pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law.
_________________________...
File: 14-2443.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Environmental
Protection v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2443/14 (Aug. 20, 2014)
Petitioner demonstrated that machinist is currently unfit for the
duties of his job and was properly placed on an emergency leave
pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law. Recommendati...
File: 21-1969.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Admin. For Children’s Services v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1969/21 (June 30, 2021), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (July 6, 2021), appended
In fitness proceeding brought against child protective specialist
pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law, ALJ found evidence
sufficient to e...
File: 10-2596.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
connection between mental disability and
excessive absences...shortages), with Health & Hospitals Corp. (Lincoln Medical...place employee on disability leave), citing Brockman
File: 14-866.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Financial Information Services Agency v. N.P.
OATH Index No. 866/14 (Aug. 22, 2014)
Petitioner proved that respondent is unfit to perform the duties of a
computer associate. Continued involuntary leave recommended.
______________________________________________________
...
File: 18-1750.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Transportation v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1750/18 (Apr.16, 2018)
Petitioner demonstrated that a clerical associate is currently unfit
for the duties of his job and was properly placed on an emergency
leave pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law.
Recommendatio...
File: 16-1336.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Health & Mental Hygiene v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1336/16 (June 29, 2016)
Petitioner demonstrated that respondent, a public health adviser, is
currently unfit for the duties of her job and should be on an
involuntary leave pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law....
File: 11-2141.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. E. G.
OATH Index No. 2141/11 (Dec. 13, 2011), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Mar. 5, 2012), aff’d, NYC
Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD 12-45-SA (Sept. 27, 2012)
Petitioner established that respondent has been absent in excess of
one year due to a non work-related disa...
File: 18-2089.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
New York City Housing Auth. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2089/18 (Aug. 20, 2018)
Petitioner proved that respondent is unfit to perform the duties of a
carpenter. Continued involuntary leave recommended.
______________________________________________________
NEW YORK CIT...
File: 2401323.pdf
Agency: ECB
Date: 11/13/24 12:00 AM
PNL: 10/31/24 DATE MAILED:
ATTY: EA/1321
Appeal No. 2401323 DOB v. 102-58 187th St. LLC October 31, 2024
APPEAL DECISION
The appeal of Respondent, premises owner, is granted.
Respondent appeals from a recommended decision by Judicial Hearing O...
File: 2401323.pdf
Agency: OATH_HEARINGS
Date: 11/13/24 12:00 AM
PNL: 10/31/24 DATE MAILED:
ATTY: EA/1321
Appeal No. 2401323 DOB v. 102-58 187th St. LLC October 31, 2024
APPEAL DECISION
The appeal of Respondent, premises owner, is granted.
Respondent appeals from a recommended decision by Judicial Hearing O...
File: 10-1613.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1613/10 (Mar. 15, 2010)
Respondent found to be suffering from paranoia rendering her
unable to perform her job. ALJ recommends that she be placed on
post-hearing leave of absence pursuant to section 72 of the Civil
Service Law.
_____...
File: 17-480.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Transportation v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 480/17 (Dec. 27, 2016)
Petitioner proved that, due to a mental illness, respondent is
presently unfit to perform his job and should remain on involuntary
leave.
_______________________________________________
NEW YORK C...
File: 17-2230.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Environmental
Protection v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2230/17 (Oct. 3, 2017), modified, Comm’r Dec. (Oct. 26, 2017), appended,
aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Index No. 2017-1057 (Aug. 2, 2018), appended
Petitioner failed to show that respondent was AWOL or that she
f...
File: 11-2107.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep't of Sanitation v. E.L.
OATH Index No. 2107/11 (Nov. 30, 2011), rejected, Comm’r Dec. (Mar. 15, 2012), appended
Respondent is charged with refusing to undergo a federally
mandated drug test. Evidence established that respondent was
unable to provide an adequate urine specimen for a ...
File: 15-321.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Environmental Protection v. J.B.
OATH Index No. 321/15 (Dec. 19, 2014), rejected and remanded, Comm’r Dec. (Feb. 13, 2015),
appended
DEP police officer was accused of being unfit to perform the
duties of his position and placed on involuntary leave pursuant to
Section 72 of t...
File: 21-70.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
Admin. For Children’s Services v. S.W.
OATH Index No. 0070/21 (Oct. 16, 2020), adopted in part, rejected in part, Comm’r Dec. (Nov.
12, 2020), appended
Fitness proceeding brought against child protective specialist pursuant to section
72 of the Civil Service Law. ALJ found evidence...
File: 13-1769.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/29/14 12:00 AM
New York Downtown Hospital
OATH Index Nos...based upon a disability.
ALJ found employee...was not a disability
under the NYC...NEW YORK DOWNTOWN HOSPITAL
AND ADRIANA FARGELLI...New
York Downtown Hospital (NYDH) and Adriana...complainant had a disability.
Disability
Petitioner contends that Glaude was disabled by strep throat...oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/dictionary/disability
- 9 -
hospital note directing Glaude
File: 95-595.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/29/23 12:00 AM
a job-connected disability.
For these reasons...available to the hospital under HHC's...Ms. Case's disability, and her continued long
File: 23-3242.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/9/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Social Services
(Human Resources Admin.) v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 3242/23 (Oct. 6, 2023)
Petitioner established that a job opportunity specialist has a
disability that renders her unfit to perform the duties of her position
when working physically in the office. However, ...
File: 11-931.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
the employee’s disability. Health & Hospitals Corp. (Lincoln Medical...
File: 11-931.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/16/12 12:00 AM
the employee’s disability. Health & Hospitals Corp. (Lincoln Medical...
File: 11-1404.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/25/11 12:00 AM
city employment); Health & Hospitals Corp. (Elmhurst Hospital Ctr.) v. Williams...Oct. 12, 2001) (hospital worker embezzled public...money by
accepting disability benefits while working at the hospital and failing to...employment
at the hospital on disability forms).
Moreover, this
File: 22-2386.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/4/23 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights v. DiFiore Realty, LLC
OATH Index Nos. 2386/22 & 1732/23 (July 26, 2023)
Petitioner established that respondents failed to provide disabled
tenant with a reasonable accommodation at the main entrance of an
apartment building and failed to engage in a cooperat...
File: 06-1738.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
caused by a disability, the burden shifts to the hospital to prove that her disability renders her incapable...
File: 12-1944.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/3/13 12:00 AM
at a state hospital for the mentally disabled).
In consideration of...
File: 05-143.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
not disciplinary, but disability-related.
ANALYSIS
The Hospital alleged that, between...day off. The Hospital’s attendance records...quest.
Next, the Hospital alleged that, from...In fact, the Hospital’s time records...minutes.
Finally, the Hospital alleged that four...In short, the Hospital amply made out...and has been hospitalized
on a number...when she was hospitalized.
It appears that
File: 24-2814.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/5/24 12:00 AM
Staten Island
University Hospital, Northwell Health stating...respondent had been hospitalized at that facility
since
File: 13-1769.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/15/14 12:00 AM
New York Downtown Hospital
OATH Index Nos...based upon a disability.
ALJ found employee...was not a disability
under the NYC...complainant had a disability.
Disability
Petitioner contends that Glaude was disabled by strep throat...e.g., Health & Hospitals Corp. (Elmhurst Hospital Ctr.) v. J...weekend off); Health & Hospitals Corp. (Kings County
Hospital Ctr.) v. Dedier...e.g., Health
& Hospitals Corp. (Elmhurst Hospital Ctr.) v. J
File: 06-1738.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
caused by a disability, the burden
shifts to the hospital to prove that her disability renders her incapable...
File: 23-379.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/30/24 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Gotham) v. Alston-Harris
OATH Index No. 379/23 (Jan. 16, 2024)
The credible evidence established that respondent has been continuously
absent without authorization since February 17, 2022. Termination of
employment recommended.
NEW YORK CITY OFFICE OF
ADM...
File: 06-1157.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
-13-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Health & Hospitals Corp. (Coler-Goldwater
Memorial Hospital) v. Mayo
OATH Index No. 1157/06 (Aug. 24, 2006), rev’d, Hospital Decision (Sept. 25, 2006), appended
In case where a fight ensued between two employees at work, petitioner failed to establish respo...
File: 11-1300.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
L. D. v. Riverbay Corp.
OATH Index No. 1300/11 (Aug. 26, 2011), adopted, Comm’n Dec. & Order (Jan. 9, 2012),
appended
Petitioner established that respondent provider of a housing
accommodation discriminated against a tenant who suffers from a
psychia...
File: 06-1157.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/11/11 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Coler-Goldwater
Memorial Hospital) v. Mayo
OATH Index No. 1157/06 (Aug. 24, 2006), rev’d, Hospital Dec. (Sept. 25, 2006), appended,
aff’d on other grounds, HHC Pers. Rev. Bd. (Apr. 17, 2007), appended, rev’d and remanded,
Mayo v. Personnel Review Bd., 65 A....
File: 11-1300.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 3/13/15 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
L. D. v. Riverbay Corp.
OATH Index No. 1300/11 (Aug. 26, 2011), adopted, Comm’n Dec. & Order (Jan. 9, 2012),*
appended
Petitioner established that respondent provider of a housing
accommodation discriminated against a tenant who suffers from a
psychi...
File: 14-749.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/19/15 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Coler Goldwater Hospital) v. Steele
OATH Index No. 749/14 (Jan. 23, 2014), affirmed, HHC Pers. Rev. Bd. Dec. No. 1555 (Mar. 11,
2015), appended
Service aide charged with being excessively absent and absent
without leave. Charges sustained. Termination recommend...
File: 15-433.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/21/15 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp.
(Bellevue Hospital Ctr.) v. Lewis
OATH Index No. 433/15 (Jan. 26, 2015), affirmed, HHC Pers. Rev. Bd. Dec. No. 1579 (July 8,
2015), appended
Respondent was charged with being excessively absent during a
ten-week period and a long-term absence with...
File: 20-905.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/11/22 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel. McKnight v. H & M
Hennes & Mauritz L.P. & BJW Realty LLC et al.
OATH Index No. 905/20 (Mar. 31, 2022)
The evidence established that respondents H & M and Winter
respondents, discriminated against the complainant and other
disabled patrons by faili...
File: 14-2399.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 3/13/15 12:00 AM
2014) (finding
complainant disabled under section 8...to constitute a disability under state and...See
generally Health & Hospitals Corp. (Harlem Hospital Ctr.) v. Sealey...disorder constitutes a disability under the
New...depression constitutes a disability under the federal...Pet. Ex. 8), hospital records from Long Island College Hospital detailing the
emergency
File: 07-247.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 2 -
Health and Hospitals Corp.
(Harlem Hospital Center) v. Norwood
OATH Index No. 247/07 (Jan. 16, 2007)
Clerical employee charged with excessive absences, excessive tardiness, being absent without leave, conduct unbecoming and submitting a forged doctor’s note to support her...
File: 14-911.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/17/15 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Bellevue Hospital Ctr.) v. Lewis
OATH Index No. 911/14 (Feb. 13, 2014), affirmed, HHC Pers. Rev. Bd. Dec. No. 1579 (July 8,
2015), appended
Hospital care investigator charged with excessive lateness and
excessive absence. ALJ rejected employee’s defense...
File: 12-1781.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/8/13 12:00 AM
attributable to a disability, and respondent, by...virtue of that disability, is unable to...caused by
a disability, no penalty for...be imposed. Health & Hospitals
Corp. (Lincoln Medical...to a mental disability and noting that...to pursue a
disability proceeding); Dep’t...mental or physical disability”);
Housing Auth. v...due to a disability would lead to...issue.
In a disability proceeding, petitioner bears...suffers from a disability, that he is
File: 12-1781.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/16/13 12:00 AM
attributable to a disability, and respondent, by...virtue of that disability, is unable to...caused by
a disability, no penalty for...be imposed. Health & Hospitals
Corp. (Lincoln Medical...to a mental disability and noting that...to pursue a
disability proceeding); Dep’t...mental or physical disability”);
Housing Auth. v...due to a disability would lead to...issue.
In a disability proceeding, petitioner bears...suffers from a disability, that he is
File: 57-OCB-15-(BCB-1996).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
after separation for disability.
Where an employee...reason of a disability resulting from occupational...year, unless his disability is of such...termination of such disability, make application
to...on account of disability.
I am presently...position as Sergeant, Hospital
Police. It is...the Health and Hospitals
Corp., assigned at Harlem Hospital.
In a letter...Resources at the hospital, informed Grievant that
File: 07-247.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp.
(Harlem Hospital Center) v. Norwood
OATH Index No. 247/07 (Jan. 16, 2007)
Clerical employee charged with excessive absences, excessive
tardiness, being absent without leave, conduct unbecoming and
submitting a forged doctor’s note to support her request ...
File: 09-2386.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/3/13 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Metropolitan Hospital Ctr.) v.
Ricketts
OATH Index No. 2386/09 (June 22, 2009), aff’d, 88 A.D.3d 593 (1st Dep’t 2011)
Electrician charged with one AWOL and excessive absence for ten
unscheduled absences. Due to past disciplinary penalty of 60 days,
termina...
File: 05-0462.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
Manning v. HealthFirst, LLC
OATH Index No. 462/05 (March 15, 2006), adopted, Comm’n Dec. (May 10. 2006), attached
Motion to strike respondents’ answer denied, but motion
was granted to take adverse inferences as a sanction for spoliation
o...
File: 05-0462.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
Manning v. HealthFirst, LLC
OATH Index No. 462/05 (March 15, 2006), adopted , Comm’n Dec. (May 10. 2006), attached
Motion to strike respondents’ answer denied, but motion was granted to take adverse inferences as a...
File: 22-1844.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/3/22 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Health & Mental Hygiene v. A.W.
OATH Index No. 1844/22 (Oct. 27, 2022)
Public health employee found to be absent without authorization for
over six months. Termination of employment recommended.
______________________________________________________
NEW YORK CITY OFFICE O...
File: 08-2063.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-11-
Health & Hospitals Corporation v. Rivera
OATH Index No. 2063/08 (Oct. 23, 2008)
Evidence established that respondent threatened his supervisor and was excessively late. Forty-five day suspension recommended.
______________________________________________________
NEW YORK CI...
File: 08-2063.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corporation v. Rivera
OATH Index No. 2063/08 (Oct. 23, 2008)
Evidence established that respondent threatened his supervisor and
was excessively late. Forty-five day suspension recommended.
______________________________________________________
NEW YORK CITY OFFICE ...
File: 11-OCB2d-22-BOC-2018.pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 9/7/18 12:00 AM
OSA, 11 OCB2d 22 (BOC 2018)
(Rep) (Docket No. AC-1631-16)
Summary of Decision: OSA petitioned to add the title Patient Representative to
its Staff Analyst bargaining unit. DC 37 intervened and sought to add the title to
its Clerical bargaining unit. HHC argued that Patient Represen...
File: 18-2772.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/22/19 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Gala
OATH Index No. 2772/18 (Apr. 16, 2019)
Evidence established that respondent, an emergency medical
technician (“EMT”), left a patient before other EMTs arrived to
care for the patient; falsely claimed that he had been flagged down
by a non-existent patient ...
File: 9830Edec0203.pdf
Agency: TAT
Date: 11/23/09 12:00 AM
SERGIO SCHW ARTZMAN - DECISION - 02/13/03
In the Matter of SERGIO SCHW ARTZMAN
TAT (E) 98-30 (UB) - DECISION
NEW YORK CITY TAX APPEALS TRIBUNAL
APPEALS DIVISION
UNINCORPORATED BUSINESS TAX - PETITIONER W AS AN INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR W ITH
RESPECT TO THAT PORTION OF HIS INCOME DERIVED ...
File: 07-243.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
- 2 -
- 3 -
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Health and Hospitals Corp. (Bellevue Hospital Center) v. Samuel
OATH Index No. 243/07 (Dec.20, 2006)
Petitioner established its charge that respondent willfully refused two orders to undergo psychiatric evaluation. ALJ recommends that respondent be suspende...
File: 12-771.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/8/13 12:00 AM
by his alleged disability); see also Ricketts...v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp., 88 A...caused by his disability).
Here, it is...not respondent’s disability caused her absences...002, Enforcement Guidance: Disability-Related Inquiries and...establish that a disability was the cause
File: 12-0771.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/15/12 12:00 AM
by his alleged disability); see also Ricketts...v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp., 88 A...caused by his disability).
Here, it is...not respondent’s disability caused her absences...002, Enforcement Guidance: Disability-Related Inquiries and...establish that a disability was the cause
File: 12-0771.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/16/13 12:00 AM
by his alleged disability); see also Ricketts...v. NYC Health & Hospitals Corp., 88 A...caused by his disability).
Here, it is...not respondent’s disability caused her absences...002, Enforcement Guidance: Disability-Related Inquiries and...establish that a disability was the cause
File: Aponte-Board-Order.pdf
Agency: COIB
Date: 12/22/21 12:00 AM
1
IN THE MATTER OF ROBERT APONTE
COIB CASE NO. 2018-108b
OATH INDEX NO. 2218/20
DECEMBER 14, 2021
SUMMARY: In 2016 and 2017, a Special Officer at New York City Health + Hospitals
purchased two counterfeit parking placards that contained the Health + Hospitals Police shield
insignia fr...
File: 07-1296.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
- 10 -
-7-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep’t of Correction v. Stevenson
OATH Index No. 1296/07 (Oct. 24, 2007)
The Department established that respondent has been continuously absent from her position as a correction officer in excess of one year due to a non work-related disability and that re...
File: 07-1296.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/13/10 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Stevenson
OATH Index No. 1296/07 (Oct. 24, 2007)*
The Department established that respondent has been continuously
absent from her position as a correction officer in excess of one
year due to a non work-related disability and that respondent is
unfit to perform t...
File: 11-801.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/2/14 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Sicignano
OATH Index No. 801/11 (June 30, 2011), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (May 31, 2012),
appended, rev’d and remand, 2014 NY Slip Op 50730(U) (Sup. Ct. Kings Co. 2014)
Firefighter tested positive for cocaine in random drug test.
Subsequently, firefighter wa...
File: 98-301.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
1 On July 1, 1997, the Commission’s Hearings Division was incorporated into the City’s
Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.
2 Numbers in parentheses preceded by “T” refer to pages in the hearing transcript; those
preceded by “Cx.” and “Rx.” refer respectively to the ex...
File: Torres_v_Prince.pdf
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
1
NEW YORK CITY
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
---------------------------------------------------------x
In the Matter of the Complaint of Complaint No.:
M-H-D-96-1000166
MINERVA TORRES, and MINERVA (OATH No. 301/98)
TORRES ON BEHALF OF HER TWO
MINOR CHILDREN,
Complain...
File: 10-0138.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/22/09 12:00 AM
illness constitutes a disability within the meaning...reason of a disability”). Mrs. Bruce presented...was due to disability). Accordingly, I
find...his mental
- 5 -
disability; thus, the disciplinary...dismissed. See Health & Hospitals Corp.
(Harlem Hospital Ctr.) v. Sealey...by a mental disability.
RECOMMENDATION
The disciplinary
File: 15-2238.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/4/16 12:00 AM
Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth. v. Beverley
OATH Index No. 2238/15 (Nov. 30, 2015), adopted, Auth. Dec. (Dec. 28, 2015), appended,
aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Case No. 2016-0060 (May 2, 2016), appended
Petitioner demonstrated that respondent’s excessive absenteeism
constitute...
File: 19-2055.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/12/23 12:00 AM
insufficient to show disability); Health and Hospitals
Corp. (Kings County Hospital Center) v. Justin...
File: 16-1624.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/8/17 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex. rel. Blue v. Jovic
OATH Index No. 1624/16 (Aug. 19, 2016), adopted, Comm’n Dec. & Order (May 26, 2017)
After a default hearing, ALJ held that a landlord discriminated
against a tenant and her daughter because of a disability by refusing
to provide a rea...
File: 96-699.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/2/18 12:00 AM
Housing Authority v. Caballero,
OATH Index No. 699/96 (Mar. 13, 1996)
Topic(s) : 1. Scope of “current unfitness” under Civil Service Law section 72, and when the
potential for future impairment renders an employee currently unfit
2. Whether risk o...
File: 05-462.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
Manning v. HealthFirst, LLC
OATH Index No. 462/05 (March 15, 2006)
Motion to strike respondents’ answer denied, but motion
was granted to take adverse inferences as a sanction for spoliation
of evidence. Petitioner established employment discriminati...
File: 05-462.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel.
Manning v. HealthFirst, LLC
OATH Index No. 462/05 (March 15, 2006)
Motion to strike respondents’ answer denied, but motion was granted to take adverse inferences as a sanction for spoliation of evidence. Petitioner established empl...
File: 06-1059.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
-17-
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Rosario
OATH Index No. 1059/06 (Apr. 11, 2006)
Evidence established that respondent clerical worker re-entered agency offices late at night in a state of intoxication, ushered a stranger to the agency into the offices, consumed beer there with him,...
File: 06-1059.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Rosario
OATH Index No. 1059/06 (Apr. 11, 2006), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n item No. CD07-16-
SA (Feb. 12, 2007)
Evidence established that respondent clerical worker re-entered
agency offices late at night in a state of intoxication, ushered a
...
File: 07-243.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp. (Bellevue Hospital Center) v.
Samuel
OATH Index No. 243/07 (Dec.20, 2006)
Petitioner established its charge that respondent willfully refused
two orders to undergo psychiatric evaluation. ALJ recommends
that respondent be suspended for thirty days without pay...
File: 18-2624.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/1/22 12:00 AM
Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth. v. Frans-Nanton
OATH Index No. 2624/18 (July 5, 2019), adopted in part, rejected in part, Pres. Dec. (Nov.
13, 2019), appended
Respondent, a Bridge and Tunnels officer, was charged with
excessive absenteeism over two identified periods. ALJ found that
...
File: comm_v_325.pdf
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
1
NEW YORK CITY
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
-----------------------------------------------------------------x
In the Matter of the Complaint of Index No.: 1423/98
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS,
RONNIE ELLEN RAYMOND,
Complainant,
-...
File: 15-173.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
position and should be placed on a disability leave pursuant to section 72 of the Civil...
File: 06-809.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 6 -
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1 Health and Hospitals Corp. (Jacobi Medical Center)
v. Osborne
OATH Index No. 809/06 (May 17, 2006)
Employee AWOL for 21 months argued that his heroin addiction and methadone maintenance constituted a disability for which he could not be disciplined unde...
File: 06-809.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp. (Jacobi Medical Center)
v. Osborne
OATH Index No. 809/06 (May 17, 2006)
Employee AWOL for 21 months argued that his heroin addiction
and methadone maintenance constituted a disability for which he
could not be disciplined under McEniry v. Landi, 84 N.Y.2d 554...
File: 17-1260md12.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/21/17 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel. Vincent v.
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Woodhull Hospital Ctr.)
OATH Index No. 1260/17, mem. dec. (May 4, 2017), adopted, Chair’s Order on Request for
Interlocutory Review (Dec. 12, 2017)
In employment discrimination action, employer filed motion to
comp...
File: 04-120.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
placed out on disability. Paramedic McAllan was...the Health and Hospitals Corporation stipulated to...as "permanently partially disabled" does not persuade...the Health and Hospitals Corporation to the...gives assurances that disabled paramedics may request
File: 21-1182.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/4/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Health and Mental Hygiene v. Adams
OATH Index No. 1182/21 (July 27, 2023)
Public health nurse charged with insubordination for refusing to
wear a mask at work, failing to report to work as directed in violation
of mandatory health and safety policies, and displaying unci...
File: 22-2028.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/12/23 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Harlem Hospital Ctr.) v. Ostalaza
OATH Index No. 2028/22 (Apr. 11, 2023), adopted, CEO Dec. (June 16, 2023), appended
Petitioner failed to establish that respondent was absent since May
2021, as alleged, but established that she was continuously absent
without aut...
File: 11-1997.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
suffered from a disability); see also Health & Hospitals Corp. (Metropolitan
Hospital Ctr.) v. Ricketts, OATH...
File: 24-272.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/30/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Patsakos
OATH Index No. 272/24 (Apr. 11, 2024), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (July 23, 2024),
appended
Supervisor charged with discourtesy, violating emergency leave
rules, insubordination, and failing to perform assigned tasks.
Petitioner proved 18 of 19...
File: I-225-08.pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/14/12 12:00 AM
program in a hospital, health care or...institutional inmates or hospital patients with physical...problems resulting from hospitalization,
institutionalization, disability or maladjustment.
34...programs in a hospital or correctional
institution...correctional institution or
hospital.
9. Observes the
File: I-225-08.pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/14/12 12:00 AM
program in a hospital, health care or...institutional inmates or hospital patients with physical...problems resulting from hospitalization,
institutionalization, disability or maladjustment.
34...programs in a hospital or correctional
institution...correctional institution or
hospital.
9. Observes the
File: 22-298.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/20/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Social Services
(Dep’t of Homeless Services) v. Thomas
OATH Index No. 298/22 (Jan. 6, 2022), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 30, 2023), appended,
aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Case No. 2023-0065 (Apr. 13, 2023), appended
Petitioner established that respondent demonstrated ...
File: 69-OCB-21-(BCB-2002).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
provide
proof of disability satisfactory to the...agreed with the Hospital that the
documentation...in which the
Hospital had denied the
File: 20-1155.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/12/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Social Services (Dep’t of Homeless Services)
v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1155/20 (Nov. 27, 2020), adopted, Comm’r Dec (Jan. 14, 2022), appended
Security officer charged with two years of AWOL and using
excessive force against shelter resident. ALJ sustained one year of
...
File: 13-1519.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/4/13 12:00 AM
Jackson v. Elmhurst Hospital Ctr., 2012 U...St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital Ctr., 303 Fed...d
Cir. 2008)) (disability discrimination claim rejected...requested documentation of disability may not
claim...some proof of disability. Because respondent failed
File: 09-2967.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/3/09 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Krasner
OATH Index No. 2967/09 (Aug. 18, 2009)
Petitioner proved that fire protection inspector engaged in conduct
prejudicial to good order and discipline, and disorderly and
disruptive conduct, when he loudly refused to comply with his
supervisor’s instructions, regul...
File: 13-1519-Amended.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/16/13 12:00 AM
Jackson v. Elmhurst Hospital Ctr., 2012 U...St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital Ctr., 303 Fed...d
Cir. 2008)) (disability discrimination claim rejected...requested documentation of disability may not
claim...some proof of disability. Because respondent failed
File: 09-3416amended.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Rivera
OATH Index No. 3416/09 (July 30, 2010), superseding (July 28, 2010), adopted,
Comm’r Dec. (Sept. 24, 2010), appended
Respondent, an emergency medical technician, tested positive for
cocaine in a workplace random drug test. Termination of
respondent’s employ...
File: 03-965.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Correction v. Shepheard
OATH Index No. 965/03 (Nov. 6, 2003)
Application to terminate correction captain pursuant to section 73 of
the civil service law denied where petitioner did not prove respondent
had been continuously absent for more than one year due to non-work
related disabilit...
File: 03-1533.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Buildings v Pachtman
OATH Index No. 1533/03 (Aug. 25, 2003), modified, Comm'r Dec. (September 15,2003),
appended, aff'd, 24 A.D.3d 210, 806 N.Y.S.2d 43 (1st Dep't 2005).
Respondent was charged with engaging in criminal or improper
conduct or conflict of interest surrounding an inciden...
File: 09-3416amended.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/8/12 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Rivera
OATH Index No. 3416/09 (July 30, 2010), superseding (July 28, 2010), adopted,
Comm’r Dec. (Sept. 24, 2010), appended
Respondent, an emergency medical technician, tested positive for
cocaine in a workplace random drug test. Termination of
respondent’s employ...
File: 04-1061.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp. (Renaissance Health Care
Network Diagnostic and Treatment Center) v. Lasane
OATH Index No. 1061/04 (May 24, 2004)
Long-term continuous unauthorized absence; respondent terminated.
________________________________________________________________
NEW YORK CITY OFFI...
File: 12-1850.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/26/14 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Ehrlich
OATH Index No. 1850/12 (May 21, 2013), modified, Comm’r Dec. (Nov. 25, 2013), appended,
aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. 2013-0195 (Nov. 20, 2014), appended
EMS lieutenant guilty of sleeping on duty on six occasions,
excessive lateness, AWOL and othe...
File: 19-2002.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/19/20 12:00 AM
Dep’t. of Health and Mental Hygiene v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2002/19 (Feb. 11, 2020)
Petitioner did not prove that Respondent was currently unfit to
perform duties as a school nurse. Petition is dismissed.
______________________________________________________
...
File: 9830det0701.pdf
Agency: TAT
Date: 11/25/09 12:00 AM
SERGIO SCHWARTZMAN – DETERMINATION – 07/20/01
In the Matter of SERGIO SCHWARTZMAN
TAT(H) 98-30(UB) - DETERMINATION
NEW YORK CITY TAX APPEALS TRIBUNAL
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE DIVISION
UNINCORPORATED BUSINESS TAX - A SALARIED HOSPITAL STAFF PHYSICIAN WHO
EARNED ADDITIONAL COMPENSATI...
File: Ruiz_v_arcade.pdf
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
going to the hospital, she was
advised...leave. Ruiz' next hospital visit came
after...admitted to the
hospital for five days...sent home on disability for one week...doctor at the hospital, Dr. Taverna, referred...placed her on disability for six
months...after her first hospital visit in the
File: 11-857.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
Dep't of Sanitation v. Centeno
OATH Index No. 857/11 (June 6, 2011), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n
Item No. CD 11-92-SA (Nov. 30, 2011)
Respondent is charged with stealing cleaning supplies from
the Department and two instances of insubordination. ALJ
finds that all of the charges a...
File: 11-857.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/16/12 12:00 AM
Dep't of Sanitation v. Centeno
OATH Index No. 857/11 (June 6, 2011), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n
Item No. CD 11-92-SA (Nov. 30, 2011)
Respondent is charged with stealing cleaning supplies from
the Department and two instances of insubordination. ALJ
finds that all of the charges a...
File: 9-OCB-23-(BCB-1972).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
1
City v. Podiatry Soc. Of NYS, 9 OCB 23 (BCB 1972) [Decision No.
B-23-72]
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BOARD OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
--------------------------------
In the Matter of the Impasse
-between- DECISION NO. B-23-72
THE CITY OF NEW YORK DOCKET NO. BCB I-1-72
-and-
THE P...
File: 43-OCB-4-(BCB-1989).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
Uniformed Firefighters Ass’n, 43 OCB 4 (BCB 1989) [Decision No.
B-4-89 (S)], aff’d, Uniformed Firefighters Ass’n v. Office of
Collective Bargaining, No. 12338/89 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. Oct. 30,
1989), aff'd, 163 A.D.2d 251, 558 N.Y.S.2d 72 (1st Dep't 1990).
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BO...
File: 54-OCB-2--BOC-1994-.pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 9/27/10 12:00 AM
NYSNA, et. al v. DC37, City, et. al,54 OCB 2 (BOC 1994) [2-94 (Cert.)]
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BOARD OF CERTIFICATION
------------------------------------- x
In the Matter of
NEW YORK STATE NURSES ASSOCIATION,
Petitioner.
--and-- DECISION NO. 2-94
FEDERATION OF NURSES, NEW YORK S...
File: 17-1355.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/9/18 12:00 AM
Transit Auth. v. M. K.
OATH Index No. 1355/17 (Feb. 14, 2018), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Case No. 2018-0275
(Oct. 2, 2018), appended
Petitioner established that respondent refused to submit
documentation as directed, failed to report for a mandatory
overtime shift, and ref...
File: 05-262.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health & Hospitals Corp. (Bellevue Hospital) v. Olosunde
OATH Index No. 262/05 (June 15, 2005)
Respondent was charged with falsifying his time records and being
absent without leave for two days. Petitioner failed to establish
misconduct. Judge recommended dismissal of all charges.
___________...
File: 08-228.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-9-
Human Resources Admin. v. Barnes
OATH Index No. 228/08 (Nov. 15, 2007), adopted and remanded , Administrator’s Determination, Jan. 29, 2008, appended
Respondent demonstrated that the charged misconduct was most likely due to a mental disability. The disciplinary charges shou...
File: 08-228.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Barnes
OATH Index No. 228/08 (Nov. 15, 2007), adopted and remanded, Administrator’s
Determination, Jan. 29, 2008, appended
Respondent demonstrated that the charged misconduct was most
likely due to a mental disability. The disciplinary charges should
be dism...
File: 12-941.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/22/13 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Griffin
OATH Index No. 941/12 (May 10, 2012), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv.
Comm’n Item No. CD 12-52-SA (Oct. 26, 2012)
Evidence established that respondent failed to report to new work
location, engaged in insubordinate and unprofessional conduct,
was repeatedly ...
File: 12-941.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/28/13 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Griffin
OATH Index No. 941/12 (May 10, 2012), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv.
Comm’n Item No. CD 12-52-SA (Oct. 26, 2012)
Evidence established that respondent failed to report to new work
location, engaged in insubordinate and unprofessional conduct,
was repeatedly ...
File: 13-651.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/8/13 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Massie
OATH Index No. 651/13 (Mar. 29, 2013)
Petitioner established that respondent was disrespectful towards his
supervisors, refused to conduct workshops as required by his
supervisors, completed significantly fewer discharge letters than
other counselors in his...
File: 13-651.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/2/13 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Massie
OATH Index No. 651/13 (Mar. 29, 2013)
Petitioner established that respondent was disrespectful towards his
supervisors, refused to conduct workshops as required by his
supervisors, completed significantly fewer discharge letters than
other counselors in his...
File: 97-819.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Fire Dep't v. Egan,
OATH Index No. 819/97 (Aug. 15, 1997), aff’d sub nom Egan v. Von Essen, 260 A.D.2d 479, 688
N.Y.S.2d 573 (2d Dep’t 1999).
Summary : 1.Admissions made by respondent regarding injuries and plan to cover them up with a
work related accident related by two co-workers, which ...
File: 55-OCB-2-(BCB-1995).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
The Agreement which covers the date of the Grievant's 1
discharge, i.e., May 29, 1992, is the 1991-92 Memorandum of
Agreement ("1991-92 Memorandum"). Dated April 14, 1992, it
covers the term from July 1, 1991, through June 30, 1992.
Section 2 ("Existing Terms and Conditions") of the 1991-...
File: 08-536.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 14 -
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Police Dep’t v. Cornick
OATH Index No. 536/08 (Dec. 7, 2007), rev’d , Comm’r Decision (Apr. 9, 2008), appended
Evidence found insufficient to support finding that police administrative aide was currently unfit. Petition dismissed. On review, the Com...
File: 08-536.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Police Dep’t v. Cornick
OATH Index No. 536/08 (Dec. 7, 2007), rev’d, Comm’r Decision (Apr. 9, 2008), appended
Evidence found insufficient to support finding that police
administrative aide was currently unfit. Petition dismissed. On
review, the Commissioner found petitioner proved a...
File: 08-2564.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 4/19/11 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Maresca
OATH Index No. 2564/08 (Nov. 19, 2008), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (Feb. 11, 2009),
aff’d sub nom Maresca v. Scoppetta, Index No. 13478/09 (Sup. Ct. Kings Co. Nov. 30, 2009),
appended
Firefighter was arrested for possession of cocaine and tested
positiv...
File: 05-143md.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp.
(Harlem Hospital Center) v. Norwood
OATH Index No. 143/05, mem. dec. (Mar. 7, 2005)*
*Connected case: Druyan v. Fraser, Index No. 107029/05 (Sup. Ct.
N.Y. Co. June 6, 2007), appended
Motion for reconsideration of denial of counsel’s motion to withdraw
as attorney ...
File: 20-2218.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/6/21 12:00 AM
Conflicts of Interest Board v. Aponte
OATH Index No. 2218/20 (June 10, 2021), adopted,
COIB Case No. 2018-108b (Nov. 23, 2021), appended
In a default proceeding, petitioner established that a former City
employee used fake City parking placards for his personal benefit in
violat...
File: LBO-2335-TR-696.pdf
Agency: LOFT
Date: 3/9/16 12:00 AM
NEW YORK CITY
LOFT BOARD
In tlte Matter of tlte Application of
115 West 28th Street Corp. and Eleanor
Dube
Order:
ORDER
Loft Board Order # 2335
~: 115 West 28th Street
New York, New York
IMD No.: none
Docket No. TR-0696
OATH Index No. 733/98
Based on the report and rec...
File: 05-143md2.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp.
(Harlem Hospital Center) v. Norwood
OATH Index No. 143/05, mem. dec. (June 20, 2005)
Petitioner's post-report and recommendation motion to reopen the
record to submit new evidence bearing on respondent's fitness for
duty denied where new evidence would not change the...
File: 05-721.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Comm'n on Human Rights (Orlic) v. T. K. Management, Inc.
OATH Index No. 721/05 (Apr. 14, 2005), aff'd , Comm'n Dec. (May 26, 2005), appended, aff’d sub nom , T.K. Management v. Gatling , NYLJ, Nov. 2, 2005, at 19, col. 2 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. )
On remand, ALJ found that el...
File: 05-721.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/7/11 12:00 AM
Comm'n on Human Rights ex rel. Orlic v. T. K.
Management, Inc.
OATH Index No. 721/05 (Apr. 14, 2005), aff'd, Comm’n Dec. (May 26, 2005), appended, aff’d
sub nom, T.K. Management v. Gatling, 2005 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 3593 (Sup. Ct. Queens Co. Nov.
2, 2005)
On remand, ALJ foun...
File: 09-1206.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/13/09 12:00 AM
Transit Auth. v. Felix
OATH Index No. 1206/09 (June 16, 2009)
Employee workers’ compensation benefit examiner charged with
misconduct in the form of incompetence and insubordination for
failure to complete particular work assignments timely and being
rude and disrespectful to other agen...
File: 79-OCB-13-(BCB-2007).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
Detective Investigators Association of the District Attorneys’ Offices,
79 OCB 13 (BCB 2007)
[Decision No B-13-2007] (Scope) (Docket No. BCB-2573-06) (I-246-06)
Summary of Decision: The City petitioned for a determination that eight
bargaining demands proposed by the DIA were outside the sco...
File: 21-484.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/12/21 12:00 AM
Transit Authority v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 484/21 (May 3, 2021)
Respondent activated a fire alarm on an elevator and yelled “fire”
when there was no fire, threw a metal stand at a co-worker, and
failed to report the ensuing arrest promptly. Penalty of 60 days’
suspension...
File: 06-0804.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Fire Dep't v. Kelly
OATH Index No. 804/06 (June 9, 2006), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 2, 2007),
appended
Petitioner proved that firefighter was selected randomly and tested
positive for drug use. Although r...
File: 06-0804.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-24-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1 Fire Dep't v. Kelly
OATH Index No. 804/06 (June 9, 2006), modified on penalty , Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 2, 2007), appended
Petitioner proved that firefighte...
File: 06-804.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/27/10 12:00 AM
Fire Dep't v. Kelly
OATH Index No. 804/06 (June 9, 2006), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 2, 2007),
appended, aff’d, 56 A.D.3d 475 (2d Dep’t 2008)
Petitioner proved that firefighter was selected randomly and ...
File: 08-1867.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 6 -
Housing Authority v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 1867/08 (June 26, 2008)
Authority sought to place housing assistant on involuntary leave pursuant to section 72 of the Civil Service Law, based upon diagnosis that employee has a seizure disorder. Finding that the Authority had not ...
File: 09-3416.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/3/10 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Rivera
OATH Index No. 3416/09 (July 30, 2010), superseding (July 28, 2010)
Respondent, an emergency medical technician, tested positive for
cocaine in a workplace random drug test. Termination of
respondent’s employment recommended.
____________________________________...
File: 08-2101.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/27/10 12:00 AM
Fire Dep’t v. Peltonen
OATH Index No. 2101/08 (Oct. 9, 2008), aff’d, 2009 NY Slip Op 52001U, 2009 N.Y. Misc.
2716 (Sup. Ct. Kings Co. 2009)
Petitioner proved that firefighter tested positive for cocaine use.
Although respondent suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder
(“PTSD...
File: 08-2101.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
- 6 -
- 2 -
Fire Dep’t v. Peltonen
OATH Index No. 2101/08 (Oct. 9, 2008)
Petitioner proved that firefighter tested positive for cocaine use. Although respondent suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”) related to 9/11, and his drug use was caused by his PTSD, such use wa...
File: 170243a.pdf
Agency: CPC
Date: 7/26/17 12:00 AM
1 C 170243 (A) ZMQ
CITY PLANNING COMMISSION
July 10, 2017/Calendar No. 2 C 170243 (A) ZMQ
IN THE MATTER OF an application submitted by NYC Economic Development Corporation
pursuant to Section 197-c and 201 of the New York Cit...
File: 06-804.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-15-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1 Fire Dep't v. Kelly
OATH Index No. 804/06 (June 9, 2006)
Petitioner proved that firefighter was selected randomly and tested positive for drug use. Alt...
File: 12-802.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/28/12 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. J.G.
OATH Index No. 802/12 (Mar. 9, 2012), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Aug. 23, 2012)
Evidence established that sanitation worker’s AWOL was due to
his disability. Dismissal of charges recommended as respondent
lacked requisite intent to commit misconduct.
_________...
File: 12-802.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/16/13 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. J.G.
OATH Index No. 802/12 (Mar. 9, 2012)
Evidence established that sanitation worker’s AWOL was due to
his disability. Dismissal of charges recommended as respondent
lacked requisite intent to commit misconduct.
________________________________________________...
File: 17-233.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/27/16 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Holman
OATH Index No. 223/17 (Dec. 22, 2016)
Petitioner established that respondent was discourteous,
insubordinate, absent without leave, and intoxicated while at work.
Termination of employment recommended.
___________________________________________...
File: 17-223.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/16/18 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Holman
OATH Index No. 223/17 (Dec. 22, 2016), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Index No. 2017-0161
(May 12, 2017), appended
Petitioner established that respondent was discourteous,
insubordinate, absent without leave, and intoxicated while at work.
Termi...
File: 97-1590.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Parks and Recreation v. Johnson
OATH Index No. 1590/97 (September 3, 1997)
reversed Comm’r Dec. (Sept. 18, 1997), appended.
Summary: ALJ had found that petitioner did not prove that respondent was unfit due to a mental
disability and had recommended that respondent be allowed to...
File: 63-OCB-34-(BCB-1999).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
Section 12-306 of the NYCCBL provides, in part:1
a. Improper public employer practices. It shall be an improper practice for
a public employer or its agents:
(1) to interfere with, restrain or coerce public employees in the exercise of their
rights granted in § 12-305 of this chapter;
***...
File: 04-1141.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Comm’n on Human Rights ex rel. De La Rosa v. Manhattan
and Bronx Surface Transportation Operating Auth.
OATH Index No. 1141/04 (Dec. 30, 2004), aff'd, Comm'n Dec. (Mar. 11, 2005), appended
Complainants, two individuals who travel by wheelchair, alleged
that they were discriminated against ...
File: 06-230.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-2-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Admin. for Children’s Services v. Keyes
OATH Index Nos. 230/06 and 559/06 (Mar. 13, 2006)
Petitioner established that respondent violated time and leave regulations, including the prohibitions against excessive lateness and absences without leave. Responde...
File: 06-230.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Keyes
OATH Index Nos. 230/06 and 559/06 (Mar. 13, 2006)
Petitioner established that respondent violated time and leave
regulations, including the prohibitions against excessive lateness
and absences without leave. Respondent’s evidence was
insufficie...
File: 09-972.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/2/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Duclet
OATH Index No. 972/09 (May 19, 2009)
Respondent, a correction officer, found to have been excessively
absent since 2007. Respondent also found to have been
excessively out of residence without authorization on three dates in
2007 and 2008. Penalty of t...
File: 8-OCB2d-8-BCB-2015.pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 7/29/16 12:00 AM
Kassim, 8 OCB2d 8 (BCB 2015)
(IP) (Docket No. BCB-4087-14)
Summary of Decision: Petitioner alleged that the Union breached its duty of
fair representation in violation of NYCCBL § 12-306(b) by not adequately
pursuing her complaints about HHC’s treatment of her and by failing to k...
File: 05-384.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Transportation v. Mendez
OATH Index No. 384/05 (Jan. 19, 2005)
Charge that respondent used vulgar language to a superior and
refused an assignment is sustained, as is charge that respondent was
absent without official leave. Although there was no evidence that
respondent verbally re...
File: 09-3396md.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/27/10 12:00 AM
Hawthorne et al v. Jo Vin Hacking Corp.
OATH Index No. 3396/09, mem. dec. (Oct. 21, 2009)*
Evidence established that four claimant passengers in a taxicab
whose license is owned by respondent, sustained personal injuries,
the damages for which exceed the amount covered by respondent’s
i...
File: 10064896C20160901LH.pdf
Agency: TLT
Date: 9/30/16 12:00 AM
1
Taxi & Limousine Commission v. Uladzimir Padalka
SUMMONS
10064896C
DECISION
The appeal of Uladzimir Padalka (the “respondent”) is denied.
The Hearing Officer’s decision is affirmed.
BACKGROUND
On August 15, 2016, the respondent appealed Hearing Offic...
File: 08-2564.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 23 -
Fire Dep’t v. Maresca
OATH Index No. 2564/08 (Nov. 19, 2008)
Firefighter was arrested for possession of cocaine and tested positive for cocaine use. Evidence also established that respondent suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and a permanent lung disability...
File: 13-2246.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/19/13 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2246/13 (Oct. 31, 2013)
Clerical associate accessed confidential public assistance records
without authorization; posted items on the wall of his cubicle and
maintained items in a folder on his desk to intimidate his
supervisor; provided ...
File: 10-561.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 11/30/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Darragh
OATH Index No. 561/10 (Nov. 17, 2009)
Sanitation worker charged with placing garbage pail containing
paint over civilian’s head and with being AWOL. ALJ found
evidence sufficient to prove the charges and recommended that
respondent be terminated.
______...
File: 43-OCB-29-(BCB-1989).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
The Union filed a verified answer after being informed by the Trial Examiner assigned1
to this case, that its answer would not be considered unless it was verified in accordance with the
specifications of Section 7.7 of the OCB Rules.
HHC v. CWA, 43 OCB 29 (BCB 1989) [Decision No. B-29-89 (Arb...
File: 03-1517.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Beauford
OATH Index No. 1517/03 (Dec. 5, 2003), aff'd, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm'n Item No. CD06-15-SA
(Jan. 9, 2006)
Respondent, a custodian, was AWOL on fifty-two occasions in a
four-month period and also failed to appear as directed on three
occasions for an investigator...
File: 03-1291.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Comm'n on Human Rights v. T. K. Management, Inc.
OATH Index No. 1291/03 (Oct. 27, 2003), rev'd on law, dismissed as moot, Comm'n Dec. and
Order (May 3, 2004), appended (subsequent history, on remand see OATH Index No. 721/05,
aff'd sub nom T.K. Management v. Gatling, NYLJ, Nov. 2, 2005, at 19, col...
File: 05-986.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-2-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Admin. for Children’s Services v. Goodman
OATH Index Nos. 986/05 and 1082/05 (Aug. 12, 2005)
Petitioner established that respondent committed multiple acts of misconduct, including excessive lateness and insubordination. Respondent’s evidence was insuff...
File: 05-986.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Goodman
OATH Index Nos. 986/05 and 1082/05 (Aug. 12, 2005)
Petitioner established that respondent committed multiple acts of
misconduct, including excessive lateness and insubordination.
Respondent’s evidence was insufficient to show that she suffered...
File: 05-1797.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-2-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Admin. for Children’s Services v. Solomon
OATH Index No. 1797/05 (Sept. 27, 2005)
Petitioner proved that respondent was absent without leave from November 22, 2004 to May 31, 2005. However, respondent established that she is recovering from drug addictio...
File: 05-1797.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Solomon
OATH Index No. 1797/05 (Sept. 27, 2005)
Petitioner proved that respondent was absent without leave from
November 22, 2004 to May 31, 2005. However, respondent
established that she is recovering from drug addiction and her
disability caused th...
File: 2-OCB2d-5-(BCB-2009).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 4/29/09 12:00 AM
Prior to filing the verified petition form itself, Petitioner, on September 4, filed a 53 page1
single spaced document (“September 4 Filing”) and 65 exhibits (“Pet., Ex.”), which have been
Nardiello, 2 OCB2d 5 (BCB 2009)
(IP) (Docket No. BCB-2719-08).
Summary of Decision: Petition...
File: 04-953.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Health and Hospitals Corp. (Jacobi Medical Center) v.
Hudgins
OATH Index No. 953/04 (Apr. 26, 2004)
Adjournment to locate a homeless respondent suffering from a mental
illness was denied based on two prior adjournments and the
impossibility to determine when respondent would be located and
re...
File: 10-430.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/30/13 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Finance v. Rodriguez
OATH Index No. 430/10 (Mar. 5, 2010), aff’d, 102 A.D.3d 594 (1st Dep’t
2013)
Petitioner proved that respondent engaged in unauthorized outside
employment while on sick leave and falsely testified at a worker’s
compensation hearing. Terminatio...
File: 17-2403.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/27/17 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Education v. Sunda
OATH Index No. 2403/17 (Oct. 26, 2017)
In a default proceeding, petitioner demonstrated that a customer
information representative repeatedly neglected her duties and was
insubordinate. Due to respondent’s persistent unwillingness to
perform her a...
File: 47-OCB-58-(BCB-1991).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
he has
been disabled since March of...entitled to a
disability pension.
Specifically, Petitioner...I have been disabled since the City...from payroll without disability. I'm
entitled to disability pension.
Petitioner requests...to "pay
the hospital bill and pay pension disability."
In documents attached...and Social Security,
Disability to pay Doctors, Hospital and drugs prescriptions
File: 21-2293.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 1/8/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Consumer and Worker Protection v. Champion
Security Services, Inc., et al.
OATH Index No. 2293/21 (Oct. 23, 2023), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 5, 2024), appended
Respondents violated the Earned Sick and Safe Time Act by: failing
to permit employees to use paid...
File: 11-1956.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/24/24 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Education v. L.C.
OATH Index No. 1956/11 (June 28, 2011), modified, Chancellor’s Dec. (Aug. 30, 2011),
appended
In a default proceeding, evidence established that respondent has
been continuously absent from work without authorization since
June 1, 2010. ALJ found that res...
File: 04-552.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Parks and Recreation v. Grant
OATH Index No. 552/04 (Feb. 19, 2004), modified on penalty, Comm'r Dec. (Mar. 26, 2004),
appended, app dism, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm'n Item No. CD05-70-D (Sept. 14, 2005)
Clerical associate's failure to submit medical documentation until
over four months aft...
File: 05-933.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Correction v. Angrum
OATH Index Nos. 933/05, 934/05 (July 13, 2006)
Respondent correction officer and captain charged with
violations of use of force directive and with making false
statements. ALJ credited respondents’ version of incident
and found proof insufficient to estab...
File: 05-933.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
-47-
Dep't of Correction v. Angrum
OATH Index Nos. 933/05, 934/05 (July 13, 2006)
Respondent correction officer and captain charged with violations of use of force directive and with making false statements. ALJ credited respondents’ version of incident and found proof insufficient to ...
File: 08-2770.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/2/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Auguste
OATH Index No. 2770/08 (Apr. 17, 2009)
Respondent correction officer found to have been out of residence
repeatedly without permission while on sick leave, failed to log in
and out properly in accordance with attendance rules, failed to
account to the ...
File: 98-646.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
1 The Commission’s Hearings Division was consolidated with the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings
on July 1, 19 97.
Cassidy v. Dep't of Correction
OATH Index No. 646/98 (Oct. 23, 1997)
aff'd, Comm'n Dec. and Order (Jan. 28, 998), appended
Summary: Complainants are four white ...
File: 7-OCB2d-1--BOC-2014-.pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 2/21/14 12:00 AM
DC 37, 7 OCB2d 1 (BOC 2014)
(Rep) (Docket Nos. RE-178-07, RU-1249-05, RU-1250-05, RU-1255-08, and AC-36-07).
Summary of Decision: In light of amendments to the NYCCBL made by Local
Law 56, the Board removed uniformed and similar-to-uniformed titles from
bargaining units containing titles t...
File: LBO-4971-PO-0034-TA-0021-151-Kent-Avenue-BK.pdf
Agency: LOFT
Date: 5/1/20 12:00 AM
NEW YORK CITY LOFT BOARD
In the Matter of the Application of
SCOTT LEVELL, Y ANIV ZION SARIG, AND
RYAN FIX
ORDER
ORDER
Loft Board Order No. 4971
Docket No. PO-0034
TA-0221
RE: 151 Kent Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
IMD No. 30068
The New York City Loft Board (ULoft Board") a...
File: 04-1617.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Williams
OATH Index No. 1617/04 (June 3, 2004)
Petitioner proved that respondent is unfit to perform the duties of her
position due to disability.
______________________________________________________
NEW YORK CITY OFFICE OF
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIALS AND HEARIN...
File: 04-2066.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Correction v. Angrum
OATH Index Nos. 2066/04, 2067/04, 2252/04, 2253/04, 2255/04, 2256/04, 2257/04 (Feb. 7,
2005)
Inmate statements found insufficient to sustain charges that four
correction captains used improper force or made false statements.
Proof also insufficient to establish t...
File: 06-0624.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Education v. Conyers
OATH Index No. 624/06 (Oct. 25, 2006), rejected, Chancellor’s Decision (Mar. 1, 2007),
appended
Although respondent was chronically late for work, evidence
established that she was entitled to the protections of the Family
Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and t...
File: 06-0624.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
PAGE
-2-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep’t of Education v. Conyers
OATH Index No. 624/06 (Oct. 25, 2006), rejected, Chancellor’s Decision (Mar. 1, 2007), appended
Although respondent was chronically late for work, evidence established that she was entitled to the protections of the F...
File: 06-624.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Education v. Conyers
OATH Index No. 624/06 (Oct. 25, 2006), rejected, Chancellor’s Decision (Mar. 1, 2007),
appended, modified on penalty, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD07-100-M (Oct. 24,
2007), appended
Although respondent was chronically late for work, evidence
estab...
File: 06-624.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
PAGE
-2-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep’t of Education v. Conyers
OATH Index No. 624/06 (Oct. 25, 2006), rejected , Chancellor’s Decision (Mar. 1, 2007), appended, modified on penalty , NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD07-100-M (Oct. 24, 2007), appended
Although respondent was c...
File: 14-1347.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/2/14 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Housing Preservation and Development v. Saliba
OATH Index No. 1347/14 (May 19, 2014)
Respondent was guilty of engaging in two verbal altercations that
caused disruption in the workplace, on one occasion using profanity,
and one instance of disrespect of a supervisor. ALJ recomm...
File: 17-532.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 6/3/20 12:00 AM
Matter of Tenants of 151 Kent Avenue, Brooklyn
OATH Index Nos. 532/17, 533/17 (Nov. 22, 2017), adopted in part, modified in part, Loft Bd.
Order No. 4971 (Apr. 23, 2020), appended
[Loft Bd. Dkt. Nos. TA-0221, PO-0034]
Three loft tenants of IMD sought protected occupancy and rent ...
File: 30-OCB-29--BOC-1982-.pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 9/27/10 12:00 AM
PBA, et. Al v. City, et. Al,30 OCB 29 (BOC 1982) [29-82 (Cert.)]
29-82 transferr
ed to
A.D.
P.B.A. v. Anderson, 17601 N.Y. Co.
S.Ct., 12/27/82.
33
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BOARD OF CERTIFICATION
-----------------------------------X
In the Matter of the Petition
of
POLIC...
File: BACA_v_97STREETCORP.pdf
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
THE CITY OF NEW YORK
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X
In the Matter of the Complaint of :
:
EDWARD LEE BACA, :
:
Complainant, : Complaint No.
: AH-92-0280
- against - :
:
119-121 EAST 97TH STREET CORP., : RECOMMENDED
DOROTHEA ROSASCO and LOU...
File: 06-882.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/2/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Malone
OATH Index No. 882/06 (Jan. 11, 2007), aff’d sub nom Malone v. Horn, 2008 N.Y. Misc.
LEXIS 8225 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. Jan. 14, 2008), appended
Absent evidence representative had appeared for respondent before
agency for same matter, ALJ denied agency's ...
File: 19-2647.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 10/2/23 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Consumer & Worker Protection v. Anonymous
OATH Index No. 2647/19 (Mar. 8, 2022), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Apr. 14, 2022), appended,
aff’d sub nom, Interrante v. City of New York, Index No. 155932/2022 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. Nov.
30, 2022), aff’d, 2023 N.Y. App. Div. LEXIS 4700 (...
File: 17-1653.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/22/17 12:00 AM
insufficient to show disability); Health and Hospitals
Corp. (Kings County Hospital Center) v. Justin...
File: 11-2141.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/12 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. E. G.
OATH Index No. 2141/11 (Dec. 13, 2011)
Petitioner established that respondent has been absent in excess of
one year due to a non work-related disability, she is currently unfit
to perform the duties of a correction officer, and may therefore be
terminated pu...
File: 07-147.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
-12-
-13-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1 Admin. for Children’s Services v. Ogunka
OATH Index No. 147/07 (Oct. 30, 2006)
Evidence, consisting of three conflicting psychiatric opinions and a few employee complaints as to loud remarks and spitting, found insufficient to support finding that child pr...
File: 07-147.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Ogunka
OATH Index No. 147/07 (Oct. 30, 2006)
Evidence, consisting of three conflicting psychiatric opinions and a
few employee complaints as to loud remarks and spitting, found
insufficient to support finding that child protective specialist
supervisor...
File: 3-OCB2d-28--BCB-2010-.pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 7/8/10 12:00 AM
Kaplin, 3 OCB2d 28 (BCB 2010)
(IP) (Docket No. BCB-2777-09)
Summary of Decision: Petitioner, a probationary Staff Nurse, claimed that the
Union breached its duty of fair representation toward her in the handling of a
disciplinary matter arising from an error in the administration of medicati...
File: CZECHOWICZ_V_HAMILTON.pdf
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
THE CITY OF NEW YORK
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x
On the Complaint of :
:
CAROL CZECHOWICZ, :
:
Complainant, : Complaint No.
: 08176354-EP
- against - : RECOMMENDED DECISION
: AND ORDER
RICHARD...
File: Manning v. HEALTHFIRST, LLC & JOSEPH CHASSE.DOC
Agency: CHR
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Manning v. HEALTHFIRST, LLC & JOSEPH CHASSE
CITY OF NEW YORK
COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
--------------------------------------------------------x
In the Matter of
Complaint #
02-1013182
KISHANA MANNING,
OATH Index #
Petitioner,
462/05
-against-
HEALTHF...
File: 03-1385.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
1
The transc ript of the seco nd day's hearin g is herein desig nated as T r. II.
Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Auth. v. Andreola
OATH Index No. 1385/03 (June 7, 2004), modified on penalty, President Dec. (July 9, 2004),
modified on penalty, Civ. Serv. Comm'n Item No. CD05-64-M (Aug. 18, 2...
File: 06-361.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-10-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep't of Probation v. Kornheiser
OATH Index No. 361/06 (Oct. 13, 2005), aff’d in part, rev’d in part , Comm’r Dec. (Oct. 17, 2005), appended
Petitioner failed to prove that respondent, who has been treated for a number of physical infirmities, is prese...
File: 06-361.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Probation v. Kornheiser
OATH Index No. 361/06 (Oct. 13, 2005), aff’d in part, rev’d in part, Comm’r Dec. (Oct.
17, 2005), appended
Petitioner failed to prove that respondent, who has been
treated for a number of physical infirmities, is presently
unable to perform his dut...
File: 07-1392.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
15
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Papa
OATH Index No. 1392/07 (Mar. 30, 2007)
Respondent was found mentally unfit to perform the duties of her job under section 72, based on testimony of psychiatrist who conducted mental status examination and evidence of her ongoing disruptive be...
File: 07-1392.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Admin. for Children’s Services v. Papa
OATH Index No. 1392/07 (Mar. 30, 2007)
Respondent was found mentally unfit to perform the duties of her
job under section 72, based on testimony of psychiatrist who
conducted mental status examination and evidence of her ongoing
disruptive behavior...
File: 08-204.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-6-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Fire Dep't v. Ceglia
OATH Index No. 204/08 (Feb. 1, 2008)
Petitioner failed to prove that respondent has a disability that prevents her from performing her duties as a supervising fire alarm dispatcher.
________________________________________________
N...
File: 08-204.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Fire Dep't v. Ceglia
OATH Index No. 204/08 (Feb. 1, 2008)
Petitioner failed to prove that respondent has a disability that
prevents her from performing her duties as a supervising fire alarm
dispatcher.
________________________________________________
NEW YORK CITY OFFICE OF
ADM...
File: 09-2664.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/3/09 12:00 AM
Human Resources Admin. v. Kissee
OATH Index No. 2664/09 (July 9, 2009)
Clerical associate charged with multiple acts of insubordination
and discourtesy. Judge recommended that all but one of the
charges be sustained and that the employee be suspended for 35
days.
___________________...
File: 12-1159.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 9/28/12 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Guarneri
OATH Index No. 1159/12 (May 22, 2012), modified on penalty, Comm’r Dec. (Aug.15, 2012),
appended
ALJ found that respondent’s conviction in Federal Court of the
misdemeanor crime of cocaine possession violated Mayoral
Executive Order 16 because it wa...
File: 14-2473.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 5/15/24 12:00 AM
duty
assignments for temporarily disabled employees should not exceed one year, except...
File: 17-2524.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/15/18 12:00 AM
Dep’t. of Transportation v. M.S.
OATH Index No. 2524/17 (Feb. 2, 2018)
Respondent’s singing, an isolated outburst in a meeting, and an
unsubstantiated complaint of unsafe operation of a city vehicle,
were insufficient to find him unfit to perform the duties of his
position und...
File: 45-OCB-60-(BCB-1990).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
Clemett v. HHC, Bellevue Hospital Center, 45 OCB 60 (BCB 1990) [Decision No.
B-60-90 (ES)]
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BOARD OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
-----------------------------------X
In the Matter of the Improper
Practice Proceeding
-between-
LLOYD E. CLEMETT, DECISION NO. ...
File: 07-2282.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 12/17/12 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Enger
OATH Index No. 2282/07 (Jan. 14, 2008), adopted, Comm’r Dec. (Jan. 28, 2008), aff’d, NYC
Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD 08-31-SA (May 30, 2008)
Respondent is charged with being absent without leave for four months
during a period of incarceration. Adm...
File: 07-593.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
-16-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep’t of Transportation v. Ferstler
OATH Index No. 593/07 (June 25, 2007)
Petitioner demonstrated that respondent engaged in a verbal altercation and threatened a fellow employee, failed to appear for a medical examination, and acted belligerently towards the doct...
File: 07-593.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Transportation v. Ferstler
OATH Index No. 593/07 (June 25, 2007)
Petitioner demonstrated that respondent engaged in a verbal
altercation and threatened a fellow employee, failed to appear for a
medical examination, and acted belligerently towards the doctor
when he later appear...
File: 07-2282.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Enger
OATH Index No. 2282/07 (Jan. 14, 2008), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv.
Comm’n Item No.CD08-31-SA (May 30, 2008)
Respondent is charged with being absent without leave for four months
during a period of incarceration. Administrative Law Judge finds that
respond...
File: 07-2282.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 22 -
Dep’t of Sanitation v. Enger
OATH Index No. 2282/07 (Jan. 14, 2008), aff’d , NYC Civ. Serv.
Comm’n Item No.CD08-31-SA (May 30, 2008)
Respondent is charged with being absent without leave for four months during a period of incarceration. Administrative Law Judge finds...
File: 61-OCB-48-(BCB-1998).pdf
Agency: OCB_BCB
Date: 8/19/09 12:00 AM
City & HRA v. L. 371, SSEU, 61 OCB 48 (BCB 1998) [Decision No. B-48-98 (Arb)]
OFFICE OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
BOARD OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
------------------------------------------------------------------------X
In the Matter of the Arbitration :
:
-between- ...
File: 05-2026.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Sanitation v. Le-Mond
OATH Index No. 2026/05 (Sept. 14, 2005), aff'd, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm'n Item No. CD06-21-
SA (Feb. 10, 2006)
Respondent pled guilty to six time and leave violations. A hearing
was conducted to determine an appropriate penalty. Judge did not
find that the circumstan...
File: 07-899.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Correction v. Swannick
OATH Index No. 899/07 (Feb. 16, 2007), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD07-87-SA
(Aug. 14, 2007)
Petitioner proved that respondent was excessively absent and
violated sick leave rules. Termination of employment
recommended.
__________________...
File: 07-899.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
-8-
SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1Dep't of Correction v. Swannick
OATH Index No. 899/07 (Feb. 16, 2007), aff’d , NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No. CD07-87-SA (Aug. 14, 2007)
Petitioner proved that respondent was excessively absent and violated sick leave rules. Termination of employment reco...
File: 08-400.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
Dep't of Correction v. Hall
OATH Index No. 400/08 (Oct. 18, 2007), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No.CD08-33-SA
(May 30, 2008)
Charge that correction officer submitted two falsified medical
notes in October 2005 sustained. Termination of employment
recommended.
________________...
File: 08-400.doc
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 2/17/09 12:00 AM
PAGE
- 14 -
Dep't of Correction v. Hall
OATH Index No. 400/08 (Oct. 18, 2007), aff’d , NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Item No.CD08-33-SA (May 30, 2008)
Charge that correction officer submitted two falsified medical notes in October 2005 sustained. Termination of employment recommended.
_____...
File: 14-1686.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 7/7/14 12:00 AM
Dept. of Environmental Protection v. Golden
OATH Index No. 1686/14 (June 27, 2014)
Respondent interfered with agency operations by opening an incubator
and removing samples without authority, was insubordinate and
neglected his duties by disobeying repeated orders to sign an ethics
agreem...
File: 17-2417.pdf
Agency: OATH_TRIALS
Date: 8/8/18 12:00 AM
Dep’t of Correction v. Rolando
OATH Index No. 2417/17 (Jan. 12, 2018), adopted, Comm’r Dec.
(Feb. 27, 2018), aff’d, NYC Civ. Serv. Comm’n Case No. 2018-0221
(July 5, 2018), appended
Correction officer charged with drinking alcohol while on duty,
with failing to perform...
File: 2-OCB2d-13-(BOC-2009).pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 4/29/09 12:00 AM
CWA, Local 1180, 2 OCB2d 13 (BOC 2009)
(Rep) (Docket No. RU-1159-94).
Summary of Decision: The Union filed a petition to amend Certification No. 41-73
to add the title Administrative Manager, Levels I and II. The City and NYCHA
argued that the title was excluded from collective bargaining as ma...
File: 2-OCB2d-13-(BOC-2009).pdf
Agency: OCB_BOC
Date: 7/15/09 12:00 AM
CWA, Local 1180, 2 OCB2d 13 (BOC 2009)
(Rep) (Docket No. RU-1159-94).
Summary of Decision: The Union filed a petition to amend Certification No. 41-73
to add the title Administrative Manager, Levels I and II. The City and NYCHA
argued that the title was excluded from collective bargaining as ma...